Messianic Jews Misrepresented in Atlantic Article

Here is an interesting but very slanted article in The Atlantic on Messianic Jews by Sarah Posner. Posner a senior editor at the online magazine Religion Dispatches applied for and got funding for her article: “Research for this article was supported by a 2012 Knight Luce Fellowship for Reporting on Global Religion.” Obviously she did not get enough funding to do proper research as she makes sweeping statements based on the views of some individuals and transforms them into the view of all Messianic Jews

I can’t say I disagree with all of her critiques of the Messianic Jewish expressions that she saw, particularly the eschatology expressed, such as: “So for Messianic Jews, how does this all end? Although they often talk about love, their end-times theories are catastrophically violent.” Although popular, this is not what all Messianic Jews believe, many Messianic Jews strongly reject the idea of a second future Holocaust awaiting Israel, citing those prophecies were fulfilled in 70 CE with the Roman attack on Jerusalem.  Neither is the right-wing American cultural/political assumptions true for all Messianic Jews. However the jaundiced attempted to paint all Messianic Jews in the same colour is not surprise considering the author consulted the highly prejudiced  Eileen Horowitz of the anti-Messianic group Jewish Israel. Horowitz advocated the burning of the New Testament and Jewish Israel continue to shamefully claim a ‘blood libel’ over accusations the Ami Ortiz bombing was an anti-missionary attack when in fact an Orthodox former anti-missionary volunteers activist was arrested and admitted to that attempted murder. Equally, the claim by Yad L’Achim spokesman Binyamin Kluger that Jack Teitel was not connected with Yad L’Achim is also false as Teitel admitted to being a volunteer for Yad L’Achim.

Posner characterises Messianic Jews thus:

“In the meantime, Messianic Jews are assiduously attempting to, essentially, redeem Israel from its Jewishness.”

This is, of course a painful accusation, but probably has some truth somewhere in it in practical terms as many expressions of Messianic Jewish community life are copies of a form of eschatalogical American fundamentalist evangelicalism more than they are Jewish in any meaningful way.

Kosher Jesus: Messianic Jews in the Holy Land.  Read here.

Asher Intrater is playing Jewish geography with me. “Are you related to Max Posner of the delicatessen business?” he asks, referring to a long-defunct establishment in Montgomery County, Maryland, where I live and where Intrater grew up and lived until he moved to Israel with his wife and four children 20 years ago. (My grandfather’s name actually was Max Posner, but he didn’t live in Maryland or own a delicatessen.)

“Our family was friends with his family,” Intrater adds, in a moment of nostalgia for his Jewish childhood on a blazing hot July day in Yad Hashmonah, a commune about 20 minutes northwest of Jerusalem. We’ve just crossed a stone path outside the building where the staff of his organization, Revive Israel, has held its daily morning prayer service.

After New Testament readings, and as the band plays songs about Jesus’s return, Intrater stepped across the circle of worshippers to tell me of a “miracle:” that everyone on his ministry team, save one, was an Israeli citizen. He seems to want to convince me — not just as a reporter, but as a Jewish one — that Messianic Jews like him represents the genuine Judaism, an authentic Israeli-ness that must be recaptured in order for Israel to be “restored.” For that to happen, its wayward people must literally come to Jesus, a process he and his followers believe will lay the groundwork for the Messiah — the one Israel, he insists, failed to recognize the first time — to return.

Though there are an estimated 175,000 to 250,000 Messianic Jews in the U.S. and 350,000 worldwide, according to various counts, they are a tiny minority in Israel — just 10,000-20,000 people by some estimates — but growing, according to both its proponents and critics. Messianic Jews believe that Jesus is the Jewish messiah, and that the Bible prophesizes that God’s plan is for him to return to Jerusalem, prevail in an apocalyptic battle with the Antichrist, and rule the world from the Temple Mount. Unlike Jews for Jesus, which focuses on bringing Jews into churches, Messianic Jews seek to make Jews believers in Jesus while still maintaining congregations that identify as Jewish and observe Jewish customs and holidays.

While these Messianic Jews are derisive of Orthodox Jewish fundamentalism (particularly what they call its “legalism”), they pick and choose some of the practices of traditional Judaism, such as weekly Torah readings — although they add New Testament verses to it.

They import to Israel many of the worship practices and the political agenda of the American Christian right. They are tightly knit with an American-born global revival movement that holds that modern-day prophets and apostles receive direct revelations from God, forming an elite army of prayer warriors on a mission to carry out God’s plans to purify Christianity, “restore” Israel, and bring the Messiah back. Following their American example, they have brought with them the religious right’s opposition to abortion, homosexuality, and Islam.

Most Messianic Jews who are Israeli citizens serve in the army, bitterly contrasting their devotion to Israel with ultra-Orthodox haredim who have been exempt from military service. Messianic Jews support the occupation, not because they support the nationalistic policies of the Israeli government, but because of the role of re-gathering Jews to Israel plays in their end-times scenario. “What the whole world is angry with what they call occupation,” said Intrater, “we don’t see it that way. We see it as being regathered, repossessing the land that is ours. We’re not occupying somebody else’s land, we’re coming to take back the land that belongs to us.” During Israel’s Operation Pillar of Cloud in Gaza, Intrater wrote in his weekly newsletter, “we are reminded that spiritual warfare is sometimes expressed on the battlefields of this world. That warfare is likely to become increasingly intense as we progress into the end times.”

At Intrater’s 200-member congregation, Ahavat Yeshua (Love of Jesus) that met in a reception hall in a nondescript office building in downtown Jerusalem, most of the congregants are young couples with young children, Israelis singing and praying on Friday afternoon with a copy of the King James Bible in their hands. Jewish prayers are said, including the priestly blessing from the Book of Numbers, but the congregational leader adds a blessing for “Yeshua HaMoshiach” (Hebrew for Jesus the Messiah), “who is our high priest.”

It’s difficult to count Messianic Jewish congregations in Israel or to know how many members congregations have. Ellen Horowitz, Content and Research Director for the Israel-based group Jewish Israel, which says it is educating Israelis about the “spiritual destruction” caused by evangelizing, estimates the total between 120 and 150 congregations. They are located all over the country, including Jerusalem, Tel Aviv, Haifa, and the Galilee. Some people will mention — but will not detail — missionaries working underground in both Israeli settlements and Palestinian areas of the West Bank.

I met two 23 year-old Messianic Jews at a café in Tel Aviv while they were attending a conference hosted by an American evangelical group. People “still think,” one said, “that accepting Yeshua [Jesus] is not kosher, but I don’t know what you ought to tell them, because I am a Jew, I was born a Jew, I am still a Jew. … It doesn’t make me less of a Jew. … I believe in the God of the Tanakh [Old Testament] and of the New Testament.”

Like other Messianic Jews, these two young men were reluctant to reveal their identity — an indication of the significant controversy that surrounds the group in Israel. Proselytizing isn’t illegal in Israel, except when offered with a material enticement or directed at a minor without their parents’ consent. Still, there’s intense social pressure against it. While Christian Zionists like megachurch pastor and Christians United for Israel founder John Hagee have pledged to Israeli leaders that they will not try to convert Jews, Messianic Jews, along with their evangelical counterparts, have made no such promises. Messianic Jews do evangelize to Jews in Israel, but it is far less aggressive and overt than their evangelizing in the United States, for example.

Their missionary efforts place them in an antagonistic position with Israel’s government, and in particular the Interior Ministry, which is controlled by a member of the far-right religious Shas party. Under Israel’s immigration laws, Jews who are considered to have abandoned their Judaism are not permitted to obtain citizenship, even if they otherwise qualify under the Law of Return.

Although they operate under the radar of most Israelis, Messianic Jews face intense opposition from haredi groups who portray Messianic Judaism as a cult endangering Israel’s Jewish identity. They accuse Messianic Jews of preying on unsuspecting secular Israeli youth, immigrants, and others insufficiently in touch with their Judaism.

Messianic Jews frequently suggest that Jews refuse to accept Jesus as the messiah because of perceived Christian anti-Semitism, or because they don’t realize that Jesus himself was a Jew. (Intrater calls Jesus “the greatest Jew in history, the greatest Israeli, the greatest rabbi that ever lived.”) But Rabbi Bentzion Kravitz, the director of Jews for Judaism, a North American group opposed to Messianic Judaism, said the reason why Jews “denied [Jesus] was because he failed to be the messiah and his followers started saying he was God.” In Judaism, said Kravitz, the messiah will be human and cannot be God or God “in a body;” to claim the messiah is divine is “idolatry.”

Binjamin Kluger, a spokesman for Yad L’Achim, a haredi organization that sees “the saving of each and every Jewish soul from Christian cults as a sacred mission,” said that while many of the first Messianic Jews in Israel were American, Russian, or Ethiopian immigrants, now most are Israeli-born. (Yad L’Achim opposes intermarriage with similar zeal, deploying its Jewish Women Rescue Division to “save” Israeli women from dating or marrying Arab men.)

Instigated largely by Yad L’Achim, opponents have engaged in protests outside the meeting places of Messianic Jews, have interfered with their businesses, and have attempted, unsuccessfully, to have Intrater prosecuted for violating the prohibition against proselytizing to minors without parental consent.

Kluger, the Yad L’Achim spokesman, tried to portray his group’s efforts in a more benign light, saying its members go to places where Messianic Jews meet “and try to talk them out of the cult.” Messianic Jewish leaders, he said, “reject the attempts of Yad L’Achim to speak to them, the leaders, and besides that, they have conducted towards their communities a demonization of Yad L’Achim, presenting it as a terror organization. … They have no incidents they can point at.”

The 2011 U.S. State Department Report on International Religious Freedom identified Yad L’Achim as an “anti-missionary” group that feeds information to the Ministry of the Interior to deny visa entry for clergy, and describes them as “harassing and occasionally assaulting” missionaries. Kluger asserted that this characterization was a result of pressure on the U.S. government by American evangelicals.

Yad L’Achim insists that it has not engaged in or supported aggression, and denies any involvement in the most notorious case of anti-Messianic violence. In 2008, Jewish terrorist Jack Teitel set a Purim basket rigged with explosives outside the home of David Ortiz, a Messianic Jew living and working in the West Bank town of Ariel, seriously injuring his teenage son. Kluger said Teitle was “never connected” with Yad L’Achim and that it is “not a violent organization.” Still, the Ortiz incident is frequently cited by Messianic Jews as evidence of why they must operate in secret.

The haredi opposition to Messianic Judaism only feeds Messianic Jews’ contention that they (and Christians) are being persecuted — something, Intrater says, he takes in stride, because “every time you have a new wave of kind of spontaneous spiritual outbreak, the people of the previous religious institutions feel threatened and they’re the ones that tend to attack.”

Read full article here

9 thoughts on “Messianic Jews Misrepresented in Atlantic Article”

  1. It seems to me, as I stand outside and observe, what occurs to me is the hypocrisy of these blind anti-messianics like Yad Lachim and Eileen Horowitz is that they are fulfilling the very hate and murderous nature that they so vehemently oppose in anti-semites. They seem not to realize that they have thus given themselves over to the same reprehensible spirit as drove the nazis. Why is it they are not so vehemently fighting equally all those other camps competing for the Jewish soul??? Eastern religions, New Age, humanism and atheism etc…??? NO- it is only Y’shua they fight and thus they have given themselves over to the spirit of anti-Messiah! But, as Rav Shaul wrote, as it was then, even so it is now, “he that was born after the flesh persecuted him that was born after the Spirit”.

  2. What will these anti-messianic Jews say when the Temple is restored and the blood sacrifices re-instituted when many of them so adamantly deny that BLOOD SACRIFICE is necessary any more for the forgiveness of sins??? Will it only be the restoration of another ritual that has no real intrinsic value??? Many of them would fight Moshe himself if he were here just as they did when he lived and thus reveal their true anti-G-d spirit. How many Jews today even really believe in their own scriptures??? For those who lay claim to Judaism, which Judaism do they defend? Reformed?Conservative? Chassidic? Or is being Jewish nothing more than having a Jewish mother???
    Until Judaism can truly be defined having ONE definition, then let all defenders of “Judaism” be silent. Y’shua is the only ONE Who will gather together into ONE all JEWS into their TRUE identity both nationally and individually!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s