Rabbi YY Jacobson Takes on Christian idea of Ressurection of Messiah

Rabbi Yossi Jacobson

Chabad Online Live report that Rabbi Jacobson discusses whether or not the resurrection of Messiah is a Christian idea. However this may also be a sideways boost to the remaining Meshichistim within Chabad who believe that The Rebbe will be raised from the dead as he is Moshiach! This does seem to be the case considering comments such as this:

“I am a non-Lubavitcher “friend of Chabad” who often visits the site, and, I’ll be honest, I became a little uncomfortable for the last few minutes when he was defending Moshiach’s resurrection from the dead as a Torah idea. OK, yes, there is such a Gemara but for 2000 years it seems klal-Yisroel has not emphasized the idea. And it also seems that pushing the idea of the Lubavitcher Rebbe zy”a being resurrected as Moshiach might alienate Yidden.”

Here is the COLL post:

“World-renowned teacher Rabbi YY Jacobson takes the Christian faith: Is Moshiach being resurrected from the dead a Christian concept?

Welcome to Monday Torah, a weekly class by Rabbi Yosef Yitzchak Jacobson, one of the most sought after speakers in the Jewish world today and spiritual leader of Congregation Bais Shmuel in Crown Heights.

This week’s class dissects a fascinating commentary of the Baal Haturim, according to which Moshe addressed Christianity in this week’s parsha, 1300 years before the birth of the Christian religion.

The class addresses some of the most fundamental ideas necessary for an understanding of the foundations of Jewish faith.

The weekly video webcast is aired on TheYeshiva.net and COLlive.com each
Monday evening.”

Click here and sign in to watch the video

see also The Death and Resurrection of the Beloved Son

Mayor of Jerusalem Voices Support for Yad L’Achim

R. Dov Lipschitz (left) with R. Yehuda Deri (right)
R. Dov Lipschitz (left) with R. Yehuda Deri (right)

Yad L’Achim is a Chabad-led organisation It is overseen primarily by three men: Alex Artovski (who has previously trained Chabad missionaries in Russia), ex-Catholic-turned-meshichist Binyamin Klugger, and his fellow meshichist, Yad L’Achim boss Dov Lipschitz.

As Haaretz points out this week, Chabad is the world’s largest Jewish missionary movement. Chabad, I believe, are quite welcome to proselytise wherever they like. However they would not extend the same rights to Messianic Jewish missionaries.

Matzav reports that Yad L’Achim are trying to bypass Israeli national law, and enforce municipal law to clamp down on proselytising activity from Yeshua-believing Jews. Under Yad L’Achim, Jack Teitel the “Jewish terrorist” was allowed to volunteer for missions and perhaps cultivate his extremist ideology and actions.

As I’ve previously noted, China have taken advice on “cult-fighting” from the Israeli antimissionary group Yad L’Achim. Yad L’Achim  feature prominently in the US State Department 2010 report on religious freedom in Israel. This includes details about the Penina Pies incident (where activists urged a boycott of a Messianic bakery), the riot in Beersheva at a Messianic house of worship, and the firebombing of a Messianic Jew’s car after his daughter was approached by Yad L’Achim activists in school.

With the exception of Tel Aviv, cities around Israel have agreed to cooperate with a Yad L’Achim initiative that aims to use little-enforced municipal bylaws to battle missionaries.

In a letter to Israel’s mayors, Yad L’Achim chairman Harav Shalom Dov Lifschitz noted that one of the strategies of the missionaries is to flood an area with their pamphlets, littering sidewalks, public squares and streets in violation of city cleanliness bylaws.

“It is incumbent upon every Jew to do what he can to stymie missionaries, to prevent them from succeeding in their ultimate goal, the destruction of the Jewish people,” he wrote.

Toward this end, Rav Lifschitz asked local leaders to enforce municipal bylaws that forbid “dispersing or distributing announcements in a public place” due to the litter and harm to the ecology they cause.

“In the event that missionaries scatter their pamphlets, we ask that you insist on enforcement of the law,” Yad L’Achim’s chairman wrote. “This includes bringing up violators on charges and imposing fines.”

The letter concludes: “It is your merit, and duty, to save Jews from shemad.”

Rav Lifschitz enclosed with his letter shocking figures on the extent of missionary activity in Israel in recent years, as well as pictures showing missionaries in action, distributing massive amounts of material that not only aimed to destroy Jewish souls, but also the appearance of major cities around the country.

Mayor of Jerusalem Nir Barkat: promises support for Yad L'Achim
Mayor of Jerusalem Nir Barkat: support for Yad L'Achim

By and large, the Yad L’Achim appeal was well-received. The mayor of Jerusalem Nir Barkat pledged not only to pass it on to the appropriate department head, but to follow up and ensure that it was carried out with maximum efficiency.

“I am hopeful that the response meets with your satisfaction,” he wrote.

The deputy mayor of Ramat Gan, Avihu Ben Moshe, said “the law will be enforced against anyone who violates it.” He asked Yad L’Achim to update his office on any illegal activity and promised that “I will deal with it personally.”

Rehovot mayor Rahamim Malul: promises to comply with Yad L'Achim
Rehovot mayor Rahamim Malul: will comply with Yad L'Achim

The mayor or Rechovot, Rachamim Malul, wrote: “I have passed on your letter, together with my recommendation, to ensure that this phenomenon is dealt with according to the law.”

The office of Haifa’s mayor acknowledged the importance of Yad L’Achim’s letter and said it would be passed on to the relevant parties in City Hall.

The deputy mayor of Ashdod, Rabbi Mordechai Leiberman, emphasized that “we see eye to eye on the severity of the phenomenon of distributing missionary pamphlets” and promised to be vigilant in enforcing city by-laws.

The one dissenting voice came from the Tel Aviv-Jaffa City Hall which refused to accede to the request. Responding on behalf of the municipality, attorney Boaz Bahrav wrote: “We recognize the Chassidim of Breslov who distribute religious material on the streets of the city and enjoy freedom of expression.” Therefore, he added, “it is doubtful that we would enforce Clause 11 of the law because of the principle of freedom of expression.”

Mayor of Tel Aviv Ron Huldai: his municipality permits Breslov, Chabad & Messianic missionary activity
Mayor of Tel Aviv Ron Huldai: his municipality permits Breslov, Chabad & Messianic missionary activity

Rav Lifschitz expressed satisfaction at the positive responses of the majority of mayors, but found it astonishing that Tel Aviv would compare legitimate Jewish activity in a Jewish country to destructive missionary activity. He turned the attention of the city’s legal department to a Supreme Court ruling (467/75) that Messianic Jews are, contrary to the misleading name, not Jews.